Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Not Your Grandma’s Marketing: Why Today’s Homes Need More Than MLS

Not Your Grandma’s Marketing: Why Today’s Homes Need More Than MLS

  • Lauren Coulter & Dina Castillo
  • 08/29/25

The MLS Isn’t Enough Anymore

There’s no question — the MLS is a vital tool in real estate. It ensures your home shows up on Zillow, Realtor.com, and Redfin. But in 2025, MLS alone is the bare minimum.

Luxury homes in the South Hills of Pittsburgh — Mt. Lebanon, Upper St. Clair, Peters Township, Nevillewood, South Fayette, Bethel Park, and Southpointe — require more than basic photos and an MLS upload. Today’s buyers expect cinematic video, lifestyle branding, and social-first campaigns that make them fall in love with a home before they step through the front door.

At Coulter & Castillo, we call this “not your grandma’s marketing.”


The Old vs. The New

Old-School Marketing (Grandma’s Version)

  • Yard sign in the lawn

  • 15 static photos on the MLS

  • Weekend open houses advertised in the newspaper

This approach worked in the 1980s. It doesn’t work for today’s South Hills luxury buyers.

Modern Luxury Marketing (Our Version)

  • Cinematic video tours that bring homes to life

  • Drone photography to highlight estates in Upper St. Clair or Peters Township

  • Instagram reels and TikTok tours that stop the scroll

  • Professional staging that turns every room into a showpiece

  • Custom brochures and digital ads that elevate the property into a lifestyle brand


Why MLS Alone Doesn’t Work

1. It’s Reactive

The MLS waits for buyers to search. Social-first marketing is proactive — it places your home in front of buyers on the platforms they use daily, whether they’re looking yet or not.

2. It Misses Relocating Buyers

Executives moving into Southpointe or Upper St. Clair may not even know which neighborhoods to search yet. They discover homes through digital ads, video tours, and LinkedIn — not by scrolling MLS listings.

3. It Doesn’t Match Luxury Expectations

A $1.5M Nevillewood golf estate deserves the same elevated marketing as a luxury property in Los Angeles or Miami. Buyers equate presentation with value, and average MLS photos don’t create that impression.


Case Studies: Modern Marketing in Action

  • Mt. Lebanon Stone Tudor: Marketed with a cinematic reel highlighting its storybook charm and walkability to Uptown. Multiple offers in under 48 hours.

  • Upper St. Clair Estate: Drone footage emphasized privacy and expansive grounds. Video campaign drove 25+ private showings the first weekend.

  • Bethel Park Colonial: TikTok reel showcasing the backyard and open kitchen went viral locally, creating 50+ showings in a single week.

  • Peters Township Retreat: Professional staging and video positioned the home as a “private getaway.” It sold within days, over asking.


Why South Hills Luxury Homes Deserve More

Each South Hills neighborhood offers unique selling points that require tailored marketing:

  • Mt. Lebanon: Historic charm, walkability, Blue Ribbon schools

  • Upper St. Clair: Estate properties, country club living

  • Peters Township: Spacious newer builds and family amenities

  • Nevillewood: Prestigious golf course lifestyle

  • South Fayette: Growing community with award-winning schools

  • Bethel Park: Space, convenience, and suburban value

  • Southpointe: Executive luxury living near corporate campuses

To attract the right buyers, marketing must highlight both the home and the lifestyle.


Why Coulter & Castillo Sets the Standard

At the Coulter & Castillo Group, we’ve built a reputation as the top marketing team in the South Hills because we go beyond the MLS. Our strategy blends:

  • PropertySpark award-winning social media campaigns

  • Compass three-phase marketing (Private Exclusive → Coming Soon → Public Launch)

  • Branding homes like luxury products (custom listing booklets, reels, and print pieces)

This isn’t old-school marketing. This is elevated, modern, and results-driven.


Conclusion: Stop Settling for Average

If your Realtor’s marketing plan stops at “MLS + yard sign,” you’re leaving money on the table. In the South Hills, buyers expect more — and sellers deserve better.

At the Coulter & Castillo Group, we consistently prove that modern marketing sells homes faster and for higher prices across Mt. Lebanon, Upper St. Clair, Peters Township, Nevillewood, South Fayette, Bethel Park, and Southpointe.

👉 Don’t settle for outdated marketing. Work with the team raising the bar in Pittsburgh real estate. Contact us today.

main

Our Group

In 2021, Lauren and Dina combined their 15+ years of experience and created the Coulter & Castillo Group. With 30+ million in sales year after year and over 600 homes sold to date, they are true experts in the Pittsburgh real estate market. Using a team approach, each client is able to receive an even higher level of service. Marketing specialists and quality professionals, this powerhouse duo thrives in exceeding their client's expectations and getting each property the attention it deserves!

Work With Us

Lauren and Dina are setting a new industry standard. They have proven processes for first-time buyers, move-up buyers, downsizers, investors, etc. They can help you with all of your real estate needs!

Follow Us On Instagram